Losing weight can seem like a struggle, as so many options claim to help make it easier. Surely, you have seen Weight Watchers commercials on TV, but is it worth it? Which is better for weight loss, Weight Watchers or calorie counting?
The good news is that you can choose either of them. Weight Watchers and calorie counting work similarly: by creating a calorie deficit. Without a calorie deficit, weight loss will not occur. Whichever you choose, however, depends solely on your lifestyle and finances. Read on to learn how to make the best choice for your needs.
Weight Watchers vs Calorie Counting
Weight Watchers (WW) and Calorie Counting are two different approaches to the same end goal: weight loss. However, they differ in that one is a “program” that you can follow, and the other requires you to keep track of the calorie contents of the foods and drinks you consume.
Contrary to popular belief, all weight loss programs, including WW, can work. Still, they only work by putting your body into a calorie deficit. A calorie deficit occurs when you burn more calories than you take in daily over time. A calorie deficit is the most critical factor in weight loss. Without a calorie deficit, fat loss will not occur.
WW and calorie counting are excellent options and will help you reach your goal, but how do you choose between them? Let’s focus on both and their similarities and differences first.
What is Weight Watchers?
Weight Watchers (WW) is a weight loss program that combines healthy eating habits using a point system, physical activity, and group support to help lose weight and improve overall health. The program was founded in 1963 by Jean Nidetch and has since become one of the most popular weight loss programs in the world as time has passed.
Weight Watchers Point System
The Weight Watchers program is based on a point system that assigns values to foods based on their nutritional content. It emphasizes eating foods that are lower in calories and higher in nutrients. These are known as Smartpoints and Fitpoints.
You will be assigned a daily points target based on age, height, weight, and gender. You are encouraged to track your food intake to stay within your points allowance. Every food you choose will have a number attached to it. Your goal is to stay within your allotted points for the day.
Healthier foods will have a lower Smartpoint number based on protein, fat, calorie, and sugar nutrient contents. Some foods also have zero points. In addition to the points system, Weight Watchers emphasizes the importance of regular physical activity, encouraging you to engage in at least 30 minutes of moderate exercise daily.
The program provides support through weekly group meetings, where you can share your experiences, receive guidance and encouragement, and learn from others. Weight Watchers has evolved over the years and offers various programs and tools to help you lose weight and improve your health. These programs and tools include personalized coaching, online resources, and mobile apps that make tracking progress and staying motivated easier.
What is Calorie Counting?
Calorie counting is the practice of tracking the number of calories you consume to manage your weight and improve your health. A calorie is a unit of measurement that represents the amount of energy contained in food and drinks. You can find the calorie contents of any food or drink item by looking at the nutrition label or the calories of each ingredient in the food if it is not prepackaged.
When you consume more calories than your body requires for energy, you will gain weight over time as your body stores the calories as fat. To count calories, you must determine the calories in the foods and drinks you consume and then track the total number throughout the day.
You can do this manually by looking up the calorie content of foods and drinks in a reference book or online database and writing them down. You can also use a calorie-counting app or website that does the tracking for you. The number of calories you need daily depends on various factors, including age, gender, weight, height, and activity level.
You will first need to calculate the amount of calories your body needs to maintain its current weight, known as Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE.) To simplify, Your TDEE is composed of the total calories burned by your body from three sources:
Your TDEE is your maintenance calories. To lose weight, you need to consume fewer calories than your maintenance calories, creating a calorie deficit to burn fat. A deficit of 200-500 calories daily is typically recommended for safe and sustainable weight loss.
Maintaining a calorie deficit safely and sustainably is essential to maintaining progress.
Finding your individualized TDEE is very easy. You can use an online calculator. There are many free TDEE calculators online. Choosing any of these calculators will give you an estimate of your maintenance calories.
However, keep in mind that these calculators only provide an estimate. Calorie counting is all based on trial and error. You begin by consuming a daily amount of calories less than your TDEE amount and track your progress for a few weeks. A few adjustments may be needed, but once you find your sweet spot, you will begin to lose weight by being in a calorie deficit.
Pros and Cons of Both: Weight Watchers vs Counting Calories
Weight Watchers and calorie counting both aim to create a calorie deficit to cause weight loss. Let’s discuss the benefits and disadvantages so you can decide what will work for you.
Pros of Weight Watchers
WW provides a structured, flexible weight loss plan emphasizing healthy eating habits and physical activity.
WW offers social support through weekly group meetings and online community forums.
WW allows for flexibility in food choices by assigning point values to foods rather than just focusing on calorie counting.
No foods are “off limits.”
WW offers personalized coaching and other resources to help you reach your weight loss goals.
Cons of Weight Watchers
WW can be expensive, especially if you opt for personalized coaching or other premium services.
Membership costs money.
WW requires tracking and monitoring food intake using points, which can be time-consuming and cumbersome, especially when eating out.
Weekly Weigh-ins.
Foods higher in sugar and fat may have higher points, discouraging you from eating them and causing you to restrict fun foods.
You may regain weight if you stop WW and do not count points.
It may not suit individuals with specific dietary restrictions or food allergies.
Pros of Calorie Counting
Calorie counting allows for flexibility in food choices, and you can tailor it to your dietary preferences and restrictions.
Calorie counting is free when using online resources or smartphone apps such as MyFitnessPal or Loseit.
You will understand energy balance clearly and make informed choices about food and portion sizes.
It is an effective way to lose weight if a calorie deficit is maintained.
No foods are restricted.
Weigh-ins are at your leisure.
Over time, you may not need to count calories, and you can make your best judgment based on the known calorie content of foods and portion control.
Keeping the weight off will be easier as you know the typical caloric contents of most foods.
Cons of Calorie Counting
It can be time-consuming and require a learning curve to track and monitor food intake accurately.
Calorie counting may not provide the social support and accountability that Weight Watchers offers. You must find this on your own.
It does not account for nutrient density or food quality, which can be important for overall health and well-being. You must research these facts on your own.
Calorie counting may not be suitable for individuals with disordered eating habits or a history of eating disorders.
Do Calorie Counting and Weight Watchers Both Work?
Both WW and calorie counting can be effective for weight loss because they are based on the principle of energy balance. This principle states that weight loss occurs when energy intake is lower than energy expenditure.
The key to success with either approach is to create a calorie deficit consisting of a balanced diet that includes nutrient-dense foods, regular physical activity, and consistent tracking and monitoring of progress. Your calorie deficit should not be too strict; otherwise, you will likely stop it completely.
To start calorie counting, you must create a calorie deficit to have a starting point. You can do this by calculating your maintenance calories and consuming a daily amount of calories below this value (200-500 calories less than maintenance). This is not as difficult as you may think it is, and over time, you may not think about it too much, and it will become a habit.
Which Should You Choose? Weight Watchers or Calorie Counting?
The answer is simple: Pick which option works for you. Ultimately, choosing between Weight Watchers and calorie counting depends on your preferences, needs, and overall goals.
Both approaches can be effective for weight loss when done correctly. They can help you achieve your desired weight and improve your health and well-being. Calorie counting is easier than you might think and can be very informative. You will learn so much about the calorie contents of typical foods you eat and how you can improve.
You can track your calories on your phone using any app of your choosing, or you can use a calorie-counting food diary instead. You do not need to restrict anything. If you want to have a dessert, go ahead and eat it. You can rearrange your other foods in the day to keep you on track.
Remember that you don’t need to restrict your favorite foods to lose weight. You don’t want to be miserable, and you want to enjoy the foods you eat. Any diet that forbids you and puts foods you love off limits to lose body fat is not worth doing.
Do you want to know another bonus? Exercise is not required. Although exercise can help you lose weight and sustain heart health, it is not essential. It is possible to shed body fat using diet alone. It all equates to calories in and calories out. You will lose body fat if you burn more calories than you consume over time.
However, remember that cardiovascular exercise is a great idea to promote heart health. If you want to experience fantastic results, add some exercise and strength training to your daily routine to boost calorie expenditure. This exercise can be something as simple as walking. You do not have to run a marathon.
In Summary
Both Weight Watchers and calorie counting can be effective for weight loss. The key to success with either approach is to create a calorie deficit sustainably and healthily, which means consuming a balanced diet that includes nutrient-dense foods and consistent tracking and monitoring of progress.
Regardless of your chosen approach, both work by putting your body into a caloric deficit. Choosing between Weight Watchers and calorie counting depends on individual preferences, needs, and goals.
Choosing an approach that aligns with your individual lifestyle and preferences and is sustainable for the long term is vital. Remember, before starting a new diet or exercise plan, it is important to discuss it with your doctor to be sure it is not contraindicated.
References
Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) | NYP. (2023). NewYork-Presbyterian. https://www.nyp.org/healthlibrary/definitions/basal-metabolic-rate-bmr
Calcagno, M., Kahleová, H., Alwarith, J., Burgess, N. N., Flores, R. A., Busta, M. L., & Barnard, N. D. (2019). The Thermic Effect of Food: A review. Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 38(6), 547–551. https://doi.org/10.1080/07315724.2018.1552544
Kim, J. Y. (2021). Optimal Diet Strategies for weight loss and weight loss maintenance. Journal of Obesity & Metabolic Syndrome, 30(1), 20–31. https://doi.org/10.7570/jomes20065
Learn about ZeroPoint foods. (2024). WeightWatchers. https://www.weightwatchers.com/nz/how-it-works/zeropoint-foods
Osilla, E. V., Safadi, A. O., & Sharma, S. (2022, September 12). Calories. StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK499909/
WeightWatchers. (2024, February 7). Evolution & history of WeightWatchers® program. WeightWatchers. https://www.weightwatchers.com/nz/blog/weight-loss/evolution-ww Assessed and Endorsed by the MedReport Medical Review Board