We all know that satisfying pop when knuckles are cracked, often sparking immediate relief or a disapproving glance from someone nearby. This everyday habit has long been surrounded by warnings of potential harm, particularly arthritis. But is there any truth to these claims, or are they simply myths passed down through generations?
Delving into the science behind knuckle cracking, this article explores what happens in our joints during that familiar sound, examines the research on its long-term effects, and dispels common misconceptions. Whether you're a chronic cracker or someone concerned about the consequences, it’s time to separate fact from fiction.
The Mechanics of Knuckle Cracking
To understand knuckle cracking, let's first look at the anatomy involved. Our knuckles, like other joints, are held together by a capsule filled with synovial fluid, which acts as a lubricant to ensure smooth movement. When you pull, bend, or twist your fingers to crack your knuckles, you’re stretching this capsule.
This stretching reduces pressure within the joint, allowing the dissolved gases in the synovial fluid to form a bubble. When the pressure drops enough, the bubble collapses or bursts, creating that familiar popping sound. This process is known as cavitation.
The sensation of relief some people experience after cracking their knuckles is theorised to be due to the stimulation of nerve endings around the joint, temporarily increasing the range of motion and providing a sense of relaxation. However, some suggest that there is also a psychological aspect to it - reinforcing the habit of associating knuckle-cracking with relaxation - a placebo effect. (1)
Common Beliefs and Myths
Knuckle cracking has been the subject of numerous myths and misconceptions, the most prevalent being that it causes arthritis. This belief likely stems from the notion that repeated stress on joints could lead to wear and tear, similar to what happens in arthritis. Other concerns include potential joint damage, decreased grip strength, and enlarged knuckles.
These myths have been perpetuated through anecdotes and warnings passed down through generations. While well-intentioned, these beliefs often lack scientific backing. To better understand the potential impacts of knuckle cracking, it's essential to delve into the research and expert opinions on the subject.
Scientific Evidence
So, what does science say? Several studies have investigated the long-term effects of knuckle cracking, with most finding no significant correlation between the habit and the development of arthritis or other joint issues.
One of the most famous studies on this topic is the self-experiment conducted by Dr. Donald Unger. For over 60 years, he cracked the knuckles on one hand while leaving the other untouched. At the end of his experiment, there was no discernible difference in the incidence of arthritis between the two hands (2).
Further research, including larger population studies, supports these findings. A comprehensive study published in the Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine examined a large group of habitual knuckle crackers and found no increase in the incidence of arthritis compared to those who didn't crack their knuckles (3). Additionally, experts from institutions like Johns Hopkins Medicine have reiterated that knuckle cracking is generally harmless and not a risk factor for arthritis (4).
Potential Downsides
While the fear of arthritis may be unfounded, knuckle cracking is not entirely without minor risks. Some people might experience temporary discomfort or swelling after cracking their knuckles, particularly if done excessively or with excessive force.
However, knuckle-cracking may be a symptom in a larger pattern of behaviour. Dr Greg Muller suggests that some people crack their knuckles as a coping mechanism for anxiety.(5)
Conclusion
In summary, the pervasive myth that knuckle cracking leads to arthritis doesn't hold up under scientific scrutiny. Research consistently shows that this habit is fairly harmless and does not cause long-term joint damage. While there are minor risks associated with excessive or forceful cracking, for most people, it remains a benign and satisfying habit.
So, the next time you hear that familiar pop, you can rest assured that your joints are safe. However, if you do experience any discomfort or wish to break the habit for personal reasons, there's no harm in finding alternative ways to keep your hands busy.
References
Singleton, H. (2024) Why cracking your knuckles is so satisfying-and if it’s really a bad habit, Science. Available at: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/is-cracking-your-knuckles-a-bad-habit (Accessed: 18 June 2024).
Unger D. Does knuckle cracking lead to arthritis of the fingers? Arthritis Rheum. 1998;41(5):949-50.
Deweber K, Olszewski M, Ortolano R. Knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis. J Am Board Fam Med. 2011;24(2):169-74.
Swezey RL. The truth about knuckle cracking: Can it cause arthritis? Johns Hopkins Medicine. 2011. Available from: https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-prevention/the-truth-about-knuckle-cracking-can-it-cause-arthritis
Schneider L. Is cracking your joints really bad for you? UT Health Austin. Available from: https://uthealthaustin.org/blog/is-cracking-your-joints-really-bad-for-you
ChatGPT-4 used for some paraphrasing and quality of writing. Assessed and Endorsed by the MedReport Medical Review Board